How the VA Wastes Medical Care for Veterans

In 2014, one of the biggest scandals in the history of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs erupted into the open when, thanks to a whistleblower at the Phoenix branch of the VA, the public learned for the first time of the secret wait lists for veterans seeking medical treatment, which VA supervisors and administrators around the country used to ration health care while making it appear that they were meeting performance targets, making them eligible to earn special bonuses.

Over four years later, the VA has struggled to fix the problem, where evidence of additional secret wait lists keeps coming up in news stories across the country.

One reason why the VA’s problems with excessive wait times for veterans seeking medical treatments have persisted was recently highlighted by the department’s Inspector General. Joe Davidson of the Washington Post reports on how policies set by the VA’s managers are tying up its medical staff to perform unnecessary exams.

A report by the VA’s Office of Inspector General says employees required veterans to undergo unwarranted medical re-examinations to continue getting benefits in more than one-third of the cases it studied.

“While re-examinations are important in the appropriate situation to ensure taxpayer dollars are appropriately spent, unwarranted reexaminations cause undue hardship for veterans,” the report said. “They also generate excessive work, resulting in significant costs and the diversion of VA personnel from veteran care and services.”

Based on its study, the inspector general estimated that employees sought unwarranted re-examinations in 19,800 cases out of 53,500 during the March-August 2017 review period. That’s 37 percent.

“VA’s goal is to ensure all Veterans receive the benefits to which they are entitled under the law,” Curt Cashour, VA’s press secretary, said by email. “While we apologize for any inconvenience to the affected Veterans, these exams were meant to ensure VA was meeting that goal.”

That’s bureaucratic box-checking in action, which over the course of the Inspector General’s six-month-long review, cost taxpayers over $10 million while not providing any worthwhile medical care to America’s veterans. Multiplied over 5 years, the amount of waste from such unnecessary examinations would exceed $100 million if the practice is allowed to persist by the VA’s administrators.

This is a direct example of a wasteful practice that has gone unchecked by the federal bureaucracy for too long, where stopping doing stupid things would make it possible for the VA to satisfactorily address its other ongoing issues with veterans waiting too long to even obtain treatment, much less unnecessary re-examinations, by freeing up its medical staffs limited resources.

That’s a win-win scenario. The only question that remains is whether the VA’s bureaucracy will see this kind of simple reform as an opportunity to pursue, or as a threat to be countered, the way it has with the Veterans Choice program, which allows veterans to escape from having to obtain medical care from the VA, but where the VA has imposed bureaucratic obstacles to obtaining timely services.


Craig Eyermann is a Research Fellow at the Independent Institute and the creator of the Government Cost Calculator at

Craig Eyermann is a Research Fellow at the Independent Institute, Managing Director of Political Calculations, and the creator of the Government Cost Calculator at
Beacon Posts by Craig Eyermann
  • Catalyst